Ought to We Stop Protecting Pets? Why More And More Ethicists Say Sure
It was a Tupperware tub of stay baby rats that made Dr Jessica Pierce start to question the idea of pet ownership. Although Pierce and Francione agree that pet possession is incorrect, both of them have pets: Pierce has two canine and a cat; Francione has six rescue canine, whom he considers refugees”. For now, the argument over whether we must always personal animals is basically theoretical: we do have pets and giving them up would possibly cause more hurt than good.
Pets are also property within the US, but 32 states, as well as Puerto Rico and Washington DC, now embrace provisions for pets under domestic violence protection orders. Moreover, as Francione suggests, caring for pets appears to many individuals to be the one space where we can really do proper by animals; convincing folks of the opposite is a hard sell.
Whereas pets stay property in the UK, the Animal Welfare Act of 2006 stipulates that pet owners should provide a basic degree of care for his or her animals. In 2001, Rhode Island changed its legislation to explain pet owners as guardians” , a transfer that some animal rights’ advocates lauded (and others criticised for being nothing …